[00:00:04]
[1.CALL TO ORDER AND ESTABLISH QUORUM]
OUR FIRST AGENDA ITEM IS THE PRAYER, PLEDGES OF ALLEGIANCE AND A MOMENT OF SILENCE.[2. OPENING PRAYER AND PLEDGES OF ALLEGIANCE/MOMENT OF SILENCE]
WILL YOU PLEASE RISE AND BOW YOUR HEADS? LORD, WE GATHER HERE TODAY TO DISCUSS MATTERS OF OUR SCHOOL COMMUNITY.WE SEEK YOUR GUIDANCE AND WISDOM.
MAY YOUR GRACE INSPIRE US TO MAKE DECISIONS THAT PROMOTE LEARNING AND UNDERSTANDING.
IT'S IN JESUS CHRIST'S NAME THAT WE PRAY.
WILL YOU PLEASE JOIN ME IN THE PLEDGE? NOW, PLEASE JOIN ME WITH A MOMENT OF SILENCE.
NEXT, OUR NEXT AGENDA ITEM IS PUBLIC COMMENTS.
[3. PUBLIC COMMENTS]
WE HAVE ONE SPEAKER TONIGHT.SO WE WILL GIVE HER THREE MINUTES.
THREE MINUTES. MISS SHELTON, WILL YOU PLEASE CALL HER TO THE PODIUM? OUR FIRST AND ONLY SPEAKER THIS EVENING IS PATRICIA ROSENTHAL.
THANK YOU BARBARA. GOOD EVENING.
MY NAME IS PATRICIA ROSENTHAL, AND I'M A SPECIAL EDUCATION TEACHER AT DODSON MIDDLE SCHOOL.
AS A FORMER EARLY CHILDHOOD TEACHER IN BRAZIL, I KNOW THE IMPORTANCE OF EARLY INTERVENTION AND ACADEMIC READINESS, NOT ONLY FOR SPECIAL EDUCATION STUDENTS, BUT FOR ALL CHILDREN.
I REALLY ADMIRE YOUR WILLINGNESS TO FIND SOLUTIONS TO PRESERVE THIS PROGRAM WITH IT'S, WHICH IS SO IMPORTANT FOR OUR STAFF, STUDENTS, AND PARENTS. LASTLY, I'M ALSO HERE REPRESENTING THE SPECIAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENTS OF WALNUT GROVE, CARROLL ELEMENTARY, EUBANKS, ANDREW INTERMEDIATE, CARROLL AND DAWSON MIDDLE SCHOOL, AND CARROLL HIGH SCHOOL TO THANK YOU FOR APPROVING THE STIPEND FOR SPECIAL EDUCATION TEACHERS AND PARAPROFESSIONALS.
IT IS A GREAT DAY TO BE A DRAGON WHEN DECISIONS LIKE THIS ARE BEING MADE.
ALL RIGHT, LET'S MOVE TO ITEM FOUR ON OUR AGENDA.
[4.1 Consider for Approval Resolution Concerning Explanation for Denial of Pre-K Tuition Rate]
ITEM 4.1 CONSIDER FOR APPROVAL RESOLUTION CONCERNING EXPLANATION FOR DENIAL OF PRE-K TUITION RATE.BEFORE WE DISCUSS THE RESOLUTION, I'D REALLY LIKE JUST TO TAKE A MOMENT TO READ THE EMAIL THAT I SENT OUT THIS WEEKEND TO THE COMMUNITY REGARDING THIS ISSUE.
IT SAYS, DEAR CARROLL ISD PARENTS, I HOPE YOU ALL ARE HAVING A GREAT WEEKEND.
I AM PLEASED TO INFORM YOU THAT THE PRE-K SITUATION HAS BEEN SUCCESSFULLY RESOLVED.
ON FRIDAY AFTERNOON, I HAD A PRODUCTIVE CONVERSATION WITH THE TEA COMMISSIONER, MIKE MORATH.
TO ALL OF THOSE IN OUR DRAGON COMMUNITY WHO SHARED THEIR CONCERNS AND OFFERED THEIR SUPPORT.
[00:05:07]
AS WE MOVE FORWARD, WE REMAIN COMMITTED TO PROVIDING EXCEPTIONAL EDUCATION OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL STUDENTS IN CARROLL ISD.YOU KNOW, I'D ALSO LIKE TO THANK OUR VERY OWN TRUSTEE YEAGER.
RELATIONSHIPS WITH YOUR ELECTED OFFICIALS ARE SO VERY IMPORTANT.
TRUSTEE YEAGER HAS AN EXCELLENT RELATIONSHIP WITH OUR STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION MEMBER, PAT HARDY.
PAT HARDY HAS A GREAT RELATIONSHIP WITH OUR TEA COMMISSIONER, MIKE MORATH.
TRUSTEE YEAGER WAS THE ONE THAT REACHED OUT TO, PAT HARDY TO CONVINCE HER TO REACH OUT TO MIKE MCGRATH TO CONVINCE HIM TO CALL ME, AND I WAS ABLE TO WALK HIM THROUGH, OUR CASE.
AND, YOU KNOW, IT'S IT'S REALLY GREAT WHEN, YOU KNOW, TEAM WORK HAPPENS.
IT WASN'T JUST ME THAT TALKED TO MIKE MCGRATH AND CONVINCED HIM IT WAS A GROUP OF PEOPLE.
AND SO I'M VERY MUCH APPRECIATIVE OF THAT.
AND, YOU KNOW, IT'S INTERESTING BECAUSE FOR YEARS THIS DISTRICT HAS BEEN ASKING FOR AN INCREASE TO THE PRE-K TUITION IN SOME BUREAUCRAT IN THE TEA JUST WROTE BACK AND SAID NO. AND SO DISTRICTS ACROSS THE STATE ARE IN THE SAME SITUATION AS WE'RE IN, AND THEY ACCEPT THAT.
SO SOMETIMES I GUESS THIS IS A LESSON LEARNED FOR ALL OF US.
AND PARENTS IN OUR COMMUNITY ARE WILLING TO PAY FOR THIS TYPE OF EDUCATION.
SO WE'RE VERY PROUD, THAT WE'RE ABLE TO, CONTINUE THIS PROGRAM.
WE ALSO HAVE A LOT OF IDEAS OF HOW TO GROW THIS PROGRAM.
YOU KNOW, AND I'LL LET TRUSTEE YEAGER TALK ABOUT THIS IN A SECOND.
IS THAT CORRECT, DOCTOR LEDBETTER? SO WHY NOT TAKE ADVANTAGE OF SOME OF THIS AND LET'S LET'S GROW THIS THING.
MAYBE THIS WILL BE AN ANSWER FOR SOME MORE STATE MONEY FOR US.
RESOLUTION CONCERNING EXPLANATION FOR DENIAL OF PRE-K TUITION RATE.
AND WHEREAS, THE CARROLL ISD BOARD OF TRUSTEES RECOGNIZES THE IMPORTANCE OF EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION IN SETTING THE FOUNDATION FOR ACADEMIC SUCCESS, AND WHEREAS THE CISD BOARD OF TRUSTEES HAS IDENTIFIED A NEED TO ADJUST PRE-K TUITION RATES TO COVER THE ADDITIONAL COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH PROVIDING TEXAS HIGH QUALITY PRE-KINDERGARTEN PROGRAMS PER TEA'S DEFINITION OF OUR PROGRAM.
AND WHEREAS, THE TEXAS EDUCATION AGENCY, UNDER THE LEADERSHIP OF COMMISSIONER MORATH, HAS REPEATEDLY DENIED OUR SCHOOL DISTRICT'S REQUEST TO RAISE THE TUITION RATE FOR OUR PRE-K PROGRAMS, DESPITE PROVIDING THOROUGH JUSTIFICATIONS FOR THE ADJUSTMENT.
AND WHEREAS THE DENIAL OF OUR REQUEST FOR A TUITION RATE INCREASE HAS PLACED UNDUE FINANCIAL STRAIN ON THE CISD BUDGET, JEOPARDIZING OUR ABILITY TO MAINTAIN THE HIGH STANDARDS OF EDUCATION OUR COMMUNITY EXPECTS AND DESERVES.
AND WHEREAS TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY ACCOUNTABILITY ARE FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF GOVERNANCE IN EDUCATION, REQUIRING CLEAR EXPLANATIONS FOR DECISIONS MADE BY STATE EDUCATION AUTHORITIES.
NOW, LET IT BE HEREBY RESOLVED THAT THE CARROLL ISD BOARD OF TRUSTEES HEREBY REQUEST AN IMMEDIATE AND DETAILED EXPLANATION FROM TEA COMMISSIONER MORATH REGARDING THE RATIONALE BEHIND THE CONTINUAL DENIAL OF OUR SCHOOL DISTRICT'S TUITION RATE REQUEST FOR PRE-K PROGRAMS THAT THE CISD BOARD OF TRUSTEES REQUEST TEA COMMISSIONER MORATH TO APPROVE CARROLL ISD'S 2024 2025 TUITION RATE REQUEST.
CONSIDERING THE COMPELLING EVIDENCE PROVIDED HERETO BY OUR DISTRICT REGARDING THE NEED FOR A TUITION INCREASE TO SUSTAIN AND ENHANCE THE TEXAS HIGH QUALITY PRE-K PROGRAMS OFFERED TO OUR STUDENTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH TEC SECTION 29.1531B1, THAT COPIES OF THIS RESOLUTION BE TRANSMITTED TO TEA, COMMISSIONER MORATH, THE TEXAS STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION, AND OTHER RELEVANT STAKEHOLDERS TO UNDERSCORE THE IMPORTANCE OF THIS MATTER TO THE CISD COMMUNITY AND TO SEEK SUPPORT FOR OUR EFFORTS TO ENSURE EQUITABLE FUNDING FOR PRE-K EDUCATION.
AND SO CAN I GET A MOTION AND A SECOND, AND THEN I'LL OPEN IT UP FOR DISCUSSION.
MOTION TO PASS THE RESOLUTION.
SECOND. WE HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND I'LL OPEN UP FOR FURTHER DISCUSSION.
[00:10:06]
THANK YOU, PRESIDENT BRIAN, FOR YOUR EFFORTS.AS PRESIDENT BRIAN SAID, HAVING RELATIONSHIPS WITH OUR STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION IS PROVED NOT ONLY ON THIS ISSUE, BUT ON OTHERS TO BE VERY IMPORTANT TO OUR COMMUNITY. THE TRIPS THAT WE'VE TAKEN AND SOME PEOPLE IN OUR COMMUNITY HAVE JOINED US.
AND SOME ACTUALLY IN OUR STAFF, I SEE ONE OF OUR PRINCIPALS.
THANK YOU, MISTER WILSON, AND KNOW THE EFFORTS THAT WE HAVE MADE AT THE STATE LEVEL.
WHEN IT COMES TO FUNDING, THIS WAS JUST KIND OF ANOTHER, MOMENT.
IF YOU TUNED IN LAST MONDAY, YOU HEARD ALL OF US IN DISBELIEF THAT WE COULDN'T CHARGE, SOMETHING TO OUR COMMUNITY, A TUITION RATE THAT FUNDED TEACHERS THAT FUNDED THIS.
IT SEEMED ABSURD AND SO WHEN THIS WAS BROUGHT TO THE COMMISSIONER'S ATTENTION, HE SAID, YOU'VE GOTTEN MISINFORMATION, YOU'VE GOTTEN WRONG DIRECTION, WHICH JUST TELLS YOU THAT'S WHY WE'RE NOT LOOKING TO PICK A FIGHT WITH THE TEA FOLKS.
WE ARE JUST TRYING TO GET RIGHT AND JUST FUNDING FOR THIS GREAT SCHOOL DISTRICT.
AND SO I'M VERY PROUD OF EVERYBODY ON THIS, BOARD HERE BECAUSE WE DID THAT.
AND, AND THAT'S THAT'S KIND OF EXCITING.
SO THANK YOU FOR BEING PATIENT FOR EVERYBODY, FOR ALL OF THE EMAILS.
IT WAS GREAT. WE LEARNED A TON.
AND THE CONVERSATIONS AND SOME HERE TEACHERS, THANK YOU FOR HAVING SOME FAITH IN US AND PATIENCE.
ANY FURTHER COMMENTS? WHEN WILL WE HAVE DOCTOR LEDBETTER? MAYBE THE PRICE OF WHAT WE'RE GOING TO CHARGE FOR TUITION.
SO I KNOW MISTER JOHNSON IS WORKING ON THAT.
HE'S WORKING ON A DETAILED APPROACH TO DETERMINE THE NUMBERS.
I KNOW HE'S GOING TO HAVE A CONVERSATION WITH EVEN REPRESENTATIVES FROM TEA, I BELIEVE, IN THE VERY NEAR FUTURE TO KIND OF COME TO A FINAL DECISION ON THAT MISTER JOHNSON TIMELINE. I SPOKE TO TEA ABOUT 4:00 THIS AFTERNOON AND TOLD THEM WHAT I'D DONE, AND WANTED TO ZOOM WITH THEM JUST SO THAT THEY WERE VERY UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT WE DID AND HOW WE DID IT. SO HOPEFULLY TOMORROW, WITHIN THE NEXT DAY OR TWO, WE SHOULD BE ABLE TO LET YOU KNOW KIND OF WHAT OUR.
THANK YOU, DOCTOR LEDBETTER. AND THE IDEA, I GUESS, IS TO THE REASON WHY WE'RE GOING AHEAD AND, CONSIDERING THIS RESOLUTION IS SO THAT WE CAN, IF IT PASSES, THAT WE CAN SEND IT AND ATTACH OUR LETTER WITH THE REFERENCE TO MY CONVERSATION WITH THE COMMISSIONER MORATH AND OUR REQUEST FOR THE TUITION INCREASE TO THAT.
THANK YOU. TRUSTEE STACY, DO YOU HAVE ANY? YEAH. I WANTED TO ASK ONE MORE THING.
I HOPE THAT OUR SPECIAL PROGRAM STAFF TAKES THAT WITH A LITTLE, A LITTLE FIREPOWER TO NOT JUST ACCEPT SOMETHING AS AN ANSWER. I KNOW IN OUR, IN OUR PRESENTATION, WE HAD A LOT OF SCHOOL DISTRICTS ON HERE THAT, THAT SAY THAT THEY DON'T OFFER, THE THREE YEAR OLD PRE-K ELIGIBLE PROGRAM AND TUITION.
I CALLED SOME OF THESE DISTRICTS, AND THEY DO.
AND SOME OF THESE DISTRICTS DON'T DO THAT.
THEY'VE BEEN TOLD SOMETHING DIFFERENT.
AND SO THEY'RE OFFERING OTHER THINGS.
AND SO I THINK IT'S KIND OF AN EYE OPENER THAT WE DON'T HAVE TO JUST TAKE THE ANSWER AS THE ANSWER.
WE CAN START ASKING SOME QUESTIONS.
POINT. THANK YOU. TRUSTEE STACEY.
AND I REALLY JUST WANT TO THANK OUR COMMUNITY.
AND, THE ATTENTION AND THAT OUR COMMUNITY PAID.
AND I JUST APPRECIATE, THE TRUST AND FAITH YOU GUYS PUT IN US TO TRY TO ADDRESS THESE THINGS.
AND THANK YOU GUYS FOR ACTUALLY GETTING IT ADDRESSED BEFORE WE EVEN HAD TO DEAL WITH IT.
AND THAT'S A GREAT POINT. TRUSTEE LANNEN AND, YOU KNOW, WE KIND OF JOKE ABOUT THE 100 EMAILS OR WHATEVER, BUT, PROBABLY NONE OF US ON THIS BOARD REALLY HAD A FULL UNDERSTANDING OF THE PRE-K PROGRAM.
BEFORE THIS ALL, ALL TOOK PLACE.
[00:15:02]
AND SO PLEASE, IF ANYBODY IN THE COMMUNITY IS LISTENING, WE READ EVERY SINGLE EMAIL, EVERY SINGLE TEXT, IF ANYBODY WANTS TO CALL AND TALK, WE ARE ALL ACCESSIBLE TO TALKING WITH YOU, TO MEETING WITH YOU.YOU'RE OUR BOSS, AND, IT'S OUR DUTY TO LISTEN TO YOU AND TO ACT, WHEN IT MAKES SENSE.
AND THIS TIME, IT IT REALLY MADE SENSE.
ANY OTHER QUESTIONS? TRUSTEES? OKAY, I HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
ALL IN FAVOR? MOTION CARRIES 6 TO 0.
THANK YOU. TRUSTEES, WE'LL MOVE ON TO ITEM NUMBER 4.2.
[4.2 Consider for Approval Revisions to Pre-K Continuum]
CONSIDER FOR APPROVAL REVISIONS TO THE PRE-K CONTINUUM.I WOULD LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND JUST JUST A MINUTE AND TABLE THIS ITEM FOR A FUTURE MEETING.
BUT BEFORE I DO THAT, I WANT TO ASK DOCTOR LEDBETTER, CAN YOU DO A COUPLE OF THINGS? CAN YOU FIRST FIND A DATE, THAT WE CAN MEET AND LONESOME DOVE OR SOME COMMON PLACE WITH WITH THE PRE-K PARENTS, WITH PRE-K TEACHERS, PRINCIPALS, THE ADMIN STUFF.
MISS BONNER, TO KIND OF WALK THROUGH SOME OF THE, THE I THINK RIGHT NOW, YOU KNOW, WE, WE HAD THOSE FOUR OPTIONS ON THE TABLE AND HAD A CERTAIN MODEL WITH CO-TEACH AND THAT TYPE OF THING.
I JUST WANT TO GET EVERYBODY'S TAKE ON WHAT THAT MIGHT BE.
SO IF YOU COULD FIGURE OUT A DATE FOR THAT AND, LET'S, LET'S GET THAT DONE SOONER THAN LATER AND THEN, YOU KNOW, THIS ITEM IS GOING TO TAKE A WHILE TO TALK ABOUT. AND I WOULD LIKE TO THEN AFTER THAT MEETING, SET UP A SEPARATE, FORMAL BOARD WORKSHOP, TO WORKSHOP THIS WITH THE ADMINISTRATION. AND SO IF YOU CAN FIND A DATE, DOCTOR LEDBETTER FOR THAT TOO, I THINK THAT WOULD BE THAT WOULD BE GREAT.
SO, WITH THAT SAID, IS IT BEFORE I MAKE A MOTION, ANYBODY HAVE ANY COMMENTS? OKAY. THE MOTION. OKAY.
YEAH. TRUSTEE YEAGER, TO MOVE, TO POSTPONE ANY ACTION ON THE APPROVAL.
APPROVAL AND REVISIONS TO THE PRE-K CONTINUUM.
SECOND. OKAY, WE'VE GOT A MOTION AND A SECOND.
ANY FURTHER DISCUSSION? ALL RIGHT, ALL IN FAVOR? MOTION CARRIES 6 TO 0.
ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
[5.EXECUTIVE SESSION]
SECTIONS 551.071, 551.074 AND 551.0821 OF THE TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE, WHICH IS COMMONLY KNOWN AS THE TEXAS OPEN MEETINGS ACT.THE BOARD WILL CONDUCT THIS HEARING IN CLOSED SESSION TO BE HELD HERE IN THE BOARDROOM.
AT THIS TIME, ALL INDIVIDUALS NOT INVOLVED WITH THE GRIEVANCE MUST PLEASE CLEAR THE BOARD ROOM.
[6. CONSIDERATION AND POSSIBLE ACTION ON ANY MATTERS ADDRESSED IN EXECUTIVE SESSION]
IN ACCORDANCE WITH CHAPTER 551 OF THE TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE, ANY ACTION REGARDING THIS MATTER MUST BE TAKEN IN OPEN SESSION.DO I HAVE A MOTION ON THE LEVEL THREE COMPLAINT? I MOVE THAT THE BOARD DENY THE LEVEL THREE GRIEVANCE FILED BY MR. AND MISS MARK, THEREBY DENYING THEIR REQUESTED RELIEF.
SECOND, I HAVE A MOTION AND A SECOND.
ALL IN FAVOR? MOTION CARRIES 6 TO 0.
IF NO OBJECTION, WE ARE NOW ADJOURNED AT 8:29 P.M..
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.